Showing posts with label BIXI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BIXI. Show all posts

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Vandalism and Theft: Resentment of Trendy Urban Middle Class

An article in The New York Times this week called “French Ideal of Bicycle-Sharing Meets Reality” describes the setbacks facing Vélib’, Paris’s bicycle rental system. The system, which operates similarly to the BIXI set-up in Montreal that I mentioned in my previous blog, has seen the consequences of public good abuse. Since its introduction in 2007, Vélib’, a government-run program, has seen 80 percent of its initial 20,600 bikes stolen or damaged. One reason for theft might be the fact that even though the rental process includes a $250 deposit, the cost of each of Vélib’ bicycle, which is specially designed, is actually $3,500. Another cause attributed to theft and vandalism has been the bicycle’s role as a symbol of the trendy urban middle class and tourism. Resentful youth in France, which are known for making their opinions known through action, have made the bicycle out to be a target of vandalism and abuse.

Similar concerns were voiced in our group’s meeting at the Rangeview courtyard a few weeks back. If we painted the shared bikes a certain distinctive color and made them out to be recognizable to act as a symbol, they might receive more negative attention than positive. The youth of Highland Park and surrounding neighborhoods might not take well to “Oxy” bikes. We can use the Paris case as evidence for potential issues.

Also, as the Alternative Transportation team writes our proposal, we need to remember to include appropriate and enforceable punishments/penalties for damages, etc. If we launch our program with too much of a relaxed policy, we could see the abuse of our program even by our own Oxy students because they see it as a resource they can do whatever they want with.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

BIXI for OXY?

The students on the Alternative Transportation Team have begun to realize the multitude of issues that must be addressed in creating a Bike Share program at Oxy. The many types of programs already in place at other institutions and cities combined with the various possibilities here at Oxy create an overwhelming sensation in and of itself. Where to begin? What approach to use? Two major proposals have already been rejected at Oxy in recent years. One proposed, for-profit proposal was too over-the-top, asking the school to purchase expensive bikes and to build a storage structure behind the Johnson Student Center. It seemed promising but was rejected because of fire code violations regarding the storage structure and the lack of funding to make the project feasible. Meanwhile, the other proposal did not provide enough promise for feasibility and wouldn’t have met Oxy’s safety requirements. Our goal must be to find the middle ground.

Oxy’s Director of Risk Management, Rebecca Dowling, is a crucial authority on the judgment of proposal feasibility. She has seen great ideas created and then rejected because underlying assumptions did not take critical liability issues into consideration. In a recent meeting with her, Mrs. Dowling told Alternative Transportation team members that she is ready to help the project by leading it in the right direction. Her support is a great tool and she said she would be willing to meet regularly. She mentioned that recent projects had also been unable to be finished due to student leaders graduating. It is essential that students realize how much time a project will take and that younger students must get involved to see a project through and be able to see the benefits.

Browsing the internet for other bike rental programs around the world, I found an interesting for-profit bike rental system in Montreal. The company, BIXI, has many “stations” throughout the city where bikes can be rented out on an hour basis. This got me thinking of why we couldn’t just contract the job of implementing a bike share program out to a company that already knows and uses an effective method. Isn’t that what we’re planning to do with Zipcar? I know it sounds lame and lazy, but if it works, why not? Instead of having students pay with a credit card, have ID cards work with the pay station and give each student a certain limited amount of credit each semester so the system isn’t abused. The school could absorb the costs and use the successful, sharp-looking, and progressive system to promote good PR to prospective students. And perhaps help the school with our sustainability grade failures…

Here’s the BIXI site: http://montreal.bixi.com/home/home-explanation

And here are some pictures of “stations” in Montreal. The company is in the process of expanding to Boston and London. Why couldn’t the model be adapted to a college campus?